Bead Police Blog
Commentary and diatribes on issues related to bead collecting. Questions to kiki@tradebeads.net or leave comments.
What passes for bead "research"

From an eBay auction (see link below):


Here's a typical example of bead "research" poverty.  I'm curious if there's any serious anthro/archeo evidence to support any of the conjecture put forth as "identification" of this bead.  Is it people are too lazy to track down supporting documentation?  Is the supporting documentation impossible to read because of language problems?  Is there any supporting documentation or are we merely dependent upon the new emerging bead folklore put forth by self-proclaimed experts?  Now we all know mosquitobay is very careful in his judgments on old beads, but what supports these judgments other than conjecture?  Really!  Where does this ID come from?  Where does this beat up bead come from?  Add it to your list of unrequited "research" topics.  I'll bet this bead proves to be early Modern Middle East.


Also, you can't expect to get much for such a beat bead on eBay without greatly exaggerating the poppycock in the style of that criminal eBay co-conspirator with the "museum" in England.  The description in this auction is too honest in its misrepresentation.


http://cgi.ebay.com/Chinese-Warring-States-Period-Stratified-Eye-Bead-RARE_W0...


2006-12-02 06:49:49 GMT
Comments (5 total)
Author:Anonymous
This is illegal "Shill" bidding. See bidders.
http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=270060444453
2006-12-02 17:48:47 GMT
Author:Anonymous
This is illegal "Shill" bidding - note that a certain bidder is bidding under three different IDs. Go figure.
2006-12-02 18:16:06 GMT
Author:Anonymous
The "ebay police" no doubt ! Is this not called bigotry ?
2006-12-02 18:25:44 GMT
Author:Anonymous
I'd call it hypocrisy!
--Foot-long Frank
2006-12-02 23:16:03 GMT
Author:Anonymous
adoberoad*upacreek and beadscollector are the same person ! Lets play break all the ebay rules. We are allowed because we are pompous pretentious arrogant bigots.And we are helping a friend.
2006-12-03 22:56:51 GMT
RSS